The Factor Guru

Tips on accounts receivable financing and business practices.

Archive for May, 2009

What Trends May Signal

May 28

Posted by Gen Merritt in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Many factoring companies utilize Trend Cards to help review accounts on a monthly basis. These management reports are a reflection of what has already occurred within a Client’s performance. Therefore, no surprises should exist as the daily account management should pick up potential concerns and changes… as they occur.

Trend Cards, however, can help identify Red Flags as a whole and can provide a tool in monitoring accounts. Most Trend Cards include a 12-month period reflected on a monthly basis showing aging trends, dilution, receivable turnover, or other data points you want to measure. These reports can be manually generated in Excel or Access; some factoring software systems may include automated reporting for this information as well.

When reviewing trends, it is important to watch for anomalies. Below are some key data points you may want to monitor more readily:

PURCHASES. For example, monthly Purchases may illustrate sudden increases or decreases in sales, which may be attributed to seasonality or even a loss of customers because of quality issues. Where sales are suddenly increasing, this may be because of recent large orders or possibly even falsification of invoices. If a Client has no Purchases during a month, this could be a Red Flag.

COLLECTIONS. Changes in Collections can signify other Red Flags. You may want to ask yourself: Are there concerns within the verification or collection calls lately? Are all the checks going to your lockbox? Are customers paying more slowly? Is this a sign of potential pre-billing? Look for consistency in the relationship between Purchases and Collections. No Collections in the last month or erratic relationships between the Purchases and Collections could be a Red Flag.

DILUTION. Dilution changes should be monitored as well. Dilution results from the non-cash deductions to receivables. This is any time an invoice is not paid in full at par (face) value; therefore, reserves are applied for discounts, short pays, charge backs, credits, and other non-cash entries. Material increases in Dilution should be addressed.

Changes in dilution may represent a change in the Client’s business or billing practices. Are more invoices being charged off, disputed, or collected by the Client directly? Has the Client grown too quickly or not been on top of billing and collections as tightly? These are questions you may want to get answered.

It is important to note that typically an advance rate is initially set based on the expected Dilution. If over time, a Client’s advance rate stays at 80% but their Dilution increases to 25%, then for a $1,000 invoice, the advance to the Client would be $800 but only $750 would be paid by their customer.

THE AGING. The aging allows you to see how a Client’s typical receivables are spread over time. Watching for anomalies in this spread is important, as an early detection method or as a note to start monitoring a Client more closely.

As you can see, trends are a historical perspective only; however, when reviewed as a whole, these trends may reveal inconsistencies that may need to be addressed. For additional information on this subject, please feel free to email me, or call the International Factoring Association for additional reference contacts.

Wishing you success. The Factor Guru.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Missing Early Warning Signs May Be Hazardous To Your Business

May 15

Posted by Gen Merritt in Operations | No Comments

 

9f7d7e4213bb1a961Changes in a company’s performance or within their business may help identify Early Warning Signs before a potential problem occurs. Knowing what to watch for can help. Here are a few more signs and ‘changes’ you may want to be on the lookout for…

Management changes or high employee turnover exists: The question to ask is why? Are there other indicators within the company or the company performance? What is the succession plan and can the business operate effectively without that key employee or manager? What affect will their absence have on the business’s ability to provide you information? Is there a problem in the business itself that would cause management or good employees to leave? Will this change affect your collateral position?

Wiring instructions change: When a company becomes overdrawn on their account, garnishments occur, their bank begins paying down other bank debts from funds received, or other changes, the business may establish another banking relationship. Companies do not normally change their operating account without a good reason. And, I have experienced other cases where the company begins asking for checks to be issued instead of their traditional wires. Again, this is a change. Therefore, this could be a red flag as well; where is that money being deposited now anyhow? Do you get bank statements on a regular basis? Is the money staying in the business?

Payment patterns from customers (debtors) change: This may be a sign of credit deterioration in the debtor, pre-billing or overbilling by a Client, etc. When a customer has always paid their invoices at 40 days, there should be a reason that an invoice remains open at 75 days. Has the approval process changed, is there paperwork that is missing to authorize a release of that check, etc. Do you understand the debtors billing and ultimate payment process? Performing verification and collection calls on purchased invoices will help identify potential problems before they occur. One thing to remember: customers (debtors) do not typically change their payment patterns overnight.

Vendors start requiring shorter terms, cash on delivery, or post dated checks: When was the last time you received an updated accounts payable aging? When cash is running tight, companies may rely on their vendors for an additional source of working capital. However, at some point, this money trail could end. Vendors tend to have closer connections with the company and in their industry than you may have; Pay attention when those same vendors suspect financial distress within your Client. (Oh, and, start requesting and reviewing those payable listings if you are not already…).   

If you begin to see one of these situations occurring, this does not mean you need to over-react. However, you do need to act. Understanding the reasons behind these occurrences is essential. You can’t fix what you don’t know.

Identifying Early Warning Signs can help eliminate or mitigate potential losses before they occur. Dealing with concerns quickly can only help your collateral position as a factor. Should an issue exist, more than likely your Client’s business has already been impacted. Don’t let their problems also become hazardous to your business. Watch for Early Warning Signs.  

Wishing You Continued Success. The Factor 

Tags: , , , , , ,

Early Warning Signs…

May 11

Posted by Gen Merritt in Operations | 1 Comment

e1bd96b3c40e992c1I realize this is out of the segment for my weblog… however, I believe this is a necessary topic to begin yet another subject: Early Warning Signs. Too many times, factoring companies come to the rescue too late. It is better to identify a problem before it actually becomes a problem. With that said, my first example: skipped invoices…

This one is tough if you don’t factor all of a company’s invoices. However, if you are factoring all of the invoices, then sometimes you need to take a closer look. Honestly, this is one of those little things that you may not pay attention to on a day to day basis. Many factors do not. It is something that seems extreme… after all, who can pay attention to everything, right?

Well, I don’t always myself. But, then you hear the story of a factor that purchased invoices wherein the debtor did not pay ultimately because of fraud that may have been recognized if the factor had first noticed the skipped invoices and those payments:

For example, a factoring company purchases invoices numbered ABC1 through ABC10; however, the company and the factor always had a long term relationship. They also had a long standing arrangement wherein the factor no longer called on all the invoices… they [the factor] had complacency in the relationship… the client account always worked well; therefore, why call on every invoice? Why call until the invoices reached the 75 day mark?

Along these lines, the next schedule included invoices ABC15 through ABC 18. Yes, some invoices had been skipped; but, again, everything on the account had worked well to date. The client account and their invoices had run well. The aging trends had deteriorated; but, the client relationship remained intact and encouraged waiting for the invoices to pay… no reason for collection calls to confirm the accuracy of the invoices based on the client history, right?

Unfortunately, the ‘real’ invoices were those with numbers from ABC11 through ABC14. Those invoices submitted prior were invoices submitted to the factor for funding only… they were not real invoices… the client had been submitting pre-billings… hoping for the work to be completed. Then, the client had invoiced for the actual work completed later.

Not only is that pre-billing, but the client had submitted invoices for funding in the second schedule for the work performed and advanced by the factor on the first schedule. Essentially, the factor had been double funding the work (i.e., funding the pre-bill and then funding the real bill). The factor just didn’t realize it because the real invoices were considered ‘non factored’ invoices and made up the difference… (If you are following this you may want to look at your client’s invoices and collections closer).

So, how do you know? Well, here are things to watch for:

-          The average pay days begin to slip; debtors do not change their payment history overnight unless a significant problem exists with that debtor’s capacity to pay. Watch for slower payments within the client and the debtor.

-          Dilution (non-cash reductions to receivables including credit memos, rebilling and billing errors, etc) increases wherein the client bills for work that has not been completed but then re-bills for work when it is ‘really’ completed.

-          The client is receiving the checks and redirecting them to the factoring lockbox… this can only been seen if the factor actually looks at the checks. Who are the checks being made out to and where are they [the checks] really being sent? Then, what do the remittance copies include? Do they match up to the invoices factored or are those checks missing the remittance (i.e., invoice numbers and amounts). Note: if you are only receiving the check image without the remittance advice, then how do you know how to apply the check accurately?

-          Trends within the client management of the account change (i.e, the client isn’t as responsive to your requests, etc).

-          The collections and the payments don’t match. Compare the payments received to those charged back, non-factored, etc as this may be telling. Do they balance? Did the non-factored money come into the lockbox? What happened to those invoices that were charged back? Did they ever actually pay? If not, why not? Do you know?

All in all, it’s about watching the collateral, looking for trends and anomalies, watching the turnover of the accounts (i.e., the DSO, collections to purchases, etc), ensuring what you purchased as a factor ties to the checks being written by the debtor, and ultimately knowing the client’s billing practices as well as the payment habits of their customers.

Knowing and recognizing these aspects helps to identify early warning signs within a portfolio… before a potential problem develops into a loss. Identifying and monitoring these concerns can ultimately help mitigate those losses, as well as provide examples to your factoring personnel of ‘things to watch for’ within a client base and portfolio. The potential of recovery is greater for those client accounts in which a factor remains proactive and aggressive. 

Again, early identification remains critical. Losses can be mitigated by seeing early warning signs wherein the collateral and performance may be deteriorating…

I could go on and on about this aspect; however, this is only one element that exists within the overall management of a client account. Ultimately, it remains a small detail of what to watch for within client performance compared to those other signs that are more commonly known. Hence, there will be more “Early Warning Signs” to come in future blogs…

Wishing You Success. The Factor Guru.

Tags: , , ,

Factoring is Like Gambling: Part I

May 5

Posted by Gen Merritt in General Information | No Comments

4d2eb19fabab5450-32Who said factoring was like gambling? Lately, now that I have been playing poker, I wanted to examine this concept… or misperception. Many people seem to say this ‘gambling’ comment flippantly only because of a perception that they believe exist. However, sometimes, you have to delve deeper… to find the truth. After all, perception is reality… right?

No. Not always, if you choose to look hard enough. So, let’s go with my basic assumption of Texas Hold ‘Em. After all, I am from Texas.  

The first rule: the one with the most bank has the best chance of winning. Do you have enough capital to play the game for the long run? Factoring is not a game you get in with limited capital. Don’t take it lightly. Real money is at stake. You have to have sufficient funds to play the game. One loss cannot dictate your endurance in running a finance company. Putting “all your eggs in one basket” may help you grow; however, can you survive the loss? If you experience losses, are you still in the game? And, will a large fraud break your bank?

If so, factoring is not the business for you… when you are new to the game. This mainly applies to those who do not do their homework, who do not understand that vigilance in underwriting and monitoring deals remains a key aspect to the factoring business. No one can teach you how to start a factoring company without also explaining the risks. It’s about your people, processes, systems… and more. Just think, all that is before you start.

You also have to understand the risks, how to mitigate those risks and how to monitor those risks over time. When you set out to start your factoring business, capital is essential… But, keeping your capital is critical. It’s not just about putting the money out there; it’s really about getting the money back!  Funny that in poker, it’s not about the risks, it’s really about getting your return (and your money back). Hmmm…

The next rule: Do you know the cards you have been dealt? Are you really looking at what’s in your hand, or are you just chasing the cards you think you have? For example, what do you offer relating to your corporate ‘tiers’ such as People, Processes, and Systems? These tiers are your strengths. Know your tiers. Know your strengths. Play to those cards. Within this,

First, know your people. Can the personnel you have handle the type of clients you are seeking? Can they handle the type of account management required for those specific accounts? Do those personnel truly understand the dynamics of various industries in which you may want to branch out into to diversity your portfolio?

Second, know your processes. Setting up procedures within your company can be essential. Think about those unique situations that require governmental regulations (i.e., Assignment of Claims, CAGE codes, etc), monitoring transportation carrier payments, or even subcontractor payments (i.e., lien releases, etc.). If the processes you have in place do not include this type of account management, then those processes are insufficient to effectively manage those types of client accounts.  

Finally, know your systems. Do you have the proper software to effectively monitor certain types of accounts? This also may include transportation, construction, or other types of processes and reporting that are being done manually within your company. Technology options exist that help monitor certain industries and assist in improving your systems to better manage your client accounts effectively.  

If you don’t know these basic tiers about your business as a factor, then how can you know what you can do? How do you even know how to read your cards? Again, if you don’t understand these fundamentals of your factoring business, you will experience challenges in managing your portfolio, let alone expanding or diversifying. Know how to read the cards you have been dealt.

With all of that said, I’ll save the next rules for another blog. But, good luck! Remember, know your capital. Know your cards.

Wishing you success in your game. The Factor Guru.

Tags: , , , , , ,