Ever wonder if you really need to look at financial statements on your clients? Yes, most factors will review the balance sheet and income statements initially, during their due diligence. Most even include financial reporting in their factoring agreements with their clients. Maybe not every factoring company chooses to do this, however, based upon their business model. Some factors focus on small, niche factoring or more collateral-based, hard verification transactions. They may determine that for smaller deals, receiving and reviewing this information is not as important during the initial underwriting process. But, here is the question, assuming you don’t have this type of business model, what about after the deal is funded?

Depending on who you talk to, you may get a different answer… only on those clients that have facilities or fundings over $100,000, over $1,000,000 or more (again, depending on who you ask) or to getting financials on every client either monthly, quarterly or annually. For those that do have certain policies in place, here is my real question: what do you do with them?

Hopefully, this is not just information that is glanced at and put in the client’s file. But, as I have been frequently asked, “What does it matter? Don’t we just need to look if they’re making or losing money?” There is no quick explanation to this question… but the answer itself is easy: No.

For one, many companies today are losing money. Secondly, if you only evaluate financial performance once, you have no trend of data for which to compare the company’s performance. Finally, it is important to compare the client’s data to your data, as the factor. What does this mean? We’ll get there… this article is not about how to read financials, but I did want to take a moment to identify the relevance from reviewing and trending all of this information. Please understand that for most of your clients, it will actually feel like you are just reviewing data and then putting the financials in the client’s file. That’s okay. For many of your client files, this is just a good check to keep you informed of what is occurring in your client’s business.

After all, factors generally evaluate their receivables weekly, review trends monthly, if not more, perform verification and collection calls and other protocols to prevent and manage risk. But, sometimes exceptions occur or complacency arises. Or, for those new to factoring and/or lending, maybe you are not familiar with all the procedures that you may want to have or should have in place for better monitoring accounts receivable and your client’s performance.

So, here is why financial monitoring can be invaluable and the event that sparked this blog.  A friend of mine called the other day to just take a ‘look’ at a company’s financials and to help explain some things to look for when they reviewed the information. We started with using the company’s prior year performance along with their interim financials (balance sheet/income statements). Now, let’s take a look at the summary information: Sales, Margins, Operating Costs and their percentages of Sales. An example is provided below, which is completely arbitrary but gets the point across (I think).

What can be gleaned from this? The company’s sales have decreased, their margins are down and their operating expenses have pretty much stayed the same… one may want to ask what is going on? Did they lose a big customer? Is there a quality issue? Are their vendors charging them more? Why hasn’t the company also lowered their overhead expenses in relation to their declining revenues? Is the company seasonal? Some would just tell you, “It’s the economy stupid.” These are just some questions for which you may want to find out more, if you don’t already know the answers.

Now, let’s look at the factoring data. During those same periods, this factor had purchased $24mm during 2008 and $17mm through 9/30/09. (And, remember these numbers are not real but exaggerated for illustrative purposes only).

But, wait! Is that right? How could purchased invoices in 2009 exceed the company’s sales?

And, there it is… that ‘light bulb’ moment… need I continue… do I really need to write out what this means…

And, before you say anything, yes, there should have been other signs in the collateral, and yet, sometimes each one of those concerns could have been reasoned away, as they probably occurred gradually, in single occurrences, over time.

Moving on… you may also want to look at certain balance sheet information such as the Accounts Receivable balances. Does their A/R balance correspond to yours for that same time period? In the example above, probably not…

Just think, we haven’t even compared the company’s A/R turnover to the factor’s A/R turnover yet. Can you guess what that information would tell you? Well, to keep this short, we can save that for another time. Just understand that “pre-bill” may be in your future if these numbers are not consistent.

Without over explaining or making this any longer than it already is, I’ll end it here. The point, however, is that checking, reviewing and comparing company financials can be important. It is only an additional tool that factoring companies and lenders rely upon in mitigating risk. But, sometimes these tools can prove to be very telling.

Wishing You Continued Success. The Factor Guru.

Tags: factor guru, factoring, financial reporting, gen merritt, prudent monitoring procedures